Right... here we go.
This took me a long time....

I Love Corpses
I Love Penguins
I Love Cock
I Love Herses(sic)
I Hate Horses
I Love Badgers
I Love Goths
I Love Sauces
I Love Preachers
I Love My Brick
Isle of Man
I Love Chocolate
I Love The Hutton Enquiry
I Love Hoses
I Eat Horses
I Love Courses
I Love Sauces
I Love Norse
Love Is...
I Love Dorset
Flash anim
I Love Hearses
I Love Dahmer
We Hates Hobbitses
I Love Wars
I Love Norse
I Love Looting
I Fucking Hate Horses
I Glove Horses
I Love Partworks
I Love Whores
I Love _____
I Love Jorges
Fisting
I Love Horses
I Love Vorhees
Eye Love Orcses
I Love Satan
I Love Scorcese
I Love Bandwagons
I'm on Hormones
DeAGONI
I Love Hosses
I Love Morses
I Love Chaucer
I Love Horses (Paintmash)
I Love Horses
I Love Forces
I Love Divorces
I Love Holeses
I Love Hearses
I Love Horses
I Love Corsas
I Love Cunts
I Love Gorses
Oi Love My Brick!
I Hear Voices
I Love Horses
I Love Hearses
I Love Divorces
I Stab Nurses
I Love Morse
I Love Whores
I Love US Special Forces
Bringing Your Horses Back to Life
I Love Sauces
I Love Arses
I Love Hoses
I Love Norses
I Love Hoses
I Love Horses
I Love Forces
I Love Norses

EDIT: There may be a few more, but that's as far back as I could be bothered to go.
( Moon Girl Technologies agent of Yahweh, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:34, archived)

you are a legend
woo
( mnb098mnb used to be here, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:34, archived)

Haha

( Sea Urchin Ceviche, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:35, archived)

i want these
in alphabetical order.
( Sir Sand GOBLIN dreary cunt, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:35, archived)

I'm leaving that
as an exercise for the student.
( Moon Girl Technologies agent of Yahweh, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:36, archived)

Who's volunteering then?
VIPER! You're a studently person. Get to it.
( HP SPEEDCORE!, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:38, archived)

eeep... ok...
i will try
( viperrr mostly comes out at night, mostly, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:42, archived)

he does make
exceedingly good posts.......
( Steak the weegie: I though I had gone?!?!?!?!?!, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:35, archived)

w00p!!
is all i have to say
( viperrr mostly comes out at night, mostly, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:36, archived)

I thank you.

( Lord_Floaty Hooting gladly., Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:36, archived)

I was going to do "I love torches"
in a sort of Kaiser-esque style, but I couldn't be arsed.
( HP SPEEDCORE!, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:36, archived)

ahem ^^

( lo, the Greebo Warrior doesn't update his sig often enough, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:36, archived)

Don't forget
I love Penguins.
( Kamikaze Stoat balanced for lean, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:36, archived)

I'm watching...
You've been told.
( Moon Girl Technologies agent of Yahweh, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:43, archived)

heheh
I've not entered this bandwagon, but I might now, just to keep you on your toes... :¬)
( Kamikaze Stoat balanced for lean, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:55, archived)

Fucking Ada !
If I lend you my
"Book of Lives"
Do you promise you'll get yourself one ?
( The Mighty Gusset Has updated his profile, but only a little bit !, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:37, archived)

Got another...
to add now, see above! God damn! So slow! That's 'cause I was looking at the ones you posted! Dorset!
(Vamos!, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:37, archived)

Nobody has done...
I Love Forceps
I Love Torsos
I Love Parsnips
( Moon Girl Technologies agent of Yahweh, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:40, archived)

or
i love faeces
(haitch, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:43, archived)

That's
disgusting.
( Moon Girl Technologies agent of Yahweh, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:47, archived)

I Love
Tossers?
Bosses?
Losses?
( Moon Girl Technologies agent of Yahweh, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:48, archived)

or

I Love Horaces
Best of all the downhill skiers
( djol, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 1:01, archived)

W00
Ha, that might put an end to it?
(Midas, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:41, archived)

who is now gonig to make
an animation of all them to the sound of our favourite song
(smokey ribena, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:43, archived)

Oh good
Mine was only the 40-somethingth post in the bandwagon. I hate joining in with these things too late
(Idid, Wed 28 Jan 2004, 0:48, archived)