By some standards, it could be unfair.
On the other hand, the mods could say, "OK, we let this one pass and we oughtn't, and we won't again. Ooops." That's what'd happen in any other situation.
( Enzyme is in ur [noun]z, [verb]in' ur [noun]z, Wed 20 Aug 2008, 14:54, archived)

It's a standardised size, and to ignore that for a single icon just seems harsh on the other people who've stuck to the guidelines.

( Ttssattsr perpetual backache of the damned, Wed 20 Aug 2008, 14:58, archived)

so are the dimensions listed in the FAQ
but people still get FPs that are way over the suggested sizes.

Let it go fella
( HappyToast sorted on, Wed 20 Aug 2008, 15:05, archived)

But that's the mods' fault
Not ours.

Similarly, it's their problem. Not ours.
( Enzyme is in ur [noun]z, [verb]in' ur [noun]z, Wed 20 Aug 2008, 15:11, archived)